In a world where critical thinking and adaptability are more valuable than ever, how we teach maths must evolve. One powerful yet underused strategy is the Goal-Free Problem—a tool that shifts the focus from simply “getting the answer” to truly understanding the problem.
What Are Goal-Free Problems?
A Goal-Free Problem is a maths question that removes the final question or objective. Instead of asking, “Find the value of x,” the problem presents a scenario and invites pupils to explore what they can deduce from the information given.
For example:
Traditional Problem: A triangle has angles of 35° and 65°. What is the third angle?
Goal-Free Version: A triangle has angles of 35° and 65°. What can you find out?
This subtle shift encourages pupils to:
- Think more broadly and flexibly
- Make connections between concepts
- Develop reasoning and justification skills
- Reduce cognitive overload by removing the pressure of a single “correct” answer
Why Goal-Free Problems Work
Research in cognitive science (notably by John Sweller and others) shows that reducing goal specificity can lower cognitive load, especially for novice learners. This allows pupils to focus on understanding relationships and structures rather than rushing to apply procedures.
In the context of the Curriculum for Wales, which emphasises deep understanding, reasoning, and problem solving, goal-free problems are a perfect fit.
How to Use Goal-Free Problems in Your Classroom
Here are some practical ways to integrate them into your teaching:
1. Starter Activities
Use goal-free problems as warm-ups to spark curiosity and discussion. Ask pupils to jot down everything they can deduce from a diagram or set of numbers.
2. Group Work
Encourage collaborative thinking by giving groups a goal-free scenario and asking them to explore it together. This promotes mathematical talk and peer learning.
3. Assessment for Learning
Use goal-free tasks to assess understanding without the pressure of a right or wrong answer. Look for the depth and variety of responses.
4. Scaffolded Problem Solving
Introduce a topic with goal-free problems before moving to more structured tasks. This helps pupils build intuition and confidence.
5. Encourage Multiple Representations
Ask pupils to represent their findings in different ways—diagrams, equations, written explanations—to deepen understanding.
Example in Action
Let’s say you’re teaching linear graphs. Instead of asking:
“Find the gradient of the line passing through (2, 3) and (6, 11),”
Try:
“Here are two points: (2, 3) and (6, 11). What can you find out?”
Pupils might:
- Calculate the gradient
- Find the equation of the line
- Plot the points
- Discuss the meaning of the gradient
- Predict other points on the line
This approach fosters exploration, creativity, and deeper learning.
Final Thoughts
Goal-Free Problems are more than a teaching trick—they’re a mindset shift. By removing the pressure of a single goal, we open the door to richer thinking, better understanding, and more confident problem solvers.
As maths teachers in Wales, we have a unique opportunity to lead this change. Let’s empower our pupils not just to solve problems—but to think like mathematicians.
Add comment
Comments